yelvington.com

The other night I gave a speech at the John Siegenthaler Center at Vanderbilt University in which I urged the new-media workshop students to look something up on Wikipedia, which is, of course, infallible. That drew a good laugh. Siegenthaler, unfortunately, wasn't appearing until later in the week, so I couldn't tease directly.

When you edit a page on Wikipedia, your changes are journaled and your identity (or at least your IP address) is noted. A Caltech grad student and hacker has built a search tool that works on that information, and Wired has launched a crowdsourced project to surface changes that are ... ahem ... interesting.

The results?

• Scientologists removing criticism. Gee, no surprise there.
• The Israeli government removing criticism.
• Electronic Arts removing criticism.
• Diebold removing ... you guessed, it, criticism!
• Dow Chemical removing references to some of its great products, such as Bhopal, Agent Orange and breast implants.
• Dell Computer ... guess what they did?
• Somebody at the Washington Post changing the record to say the Washington Examiner is owned by Charles Manson. Wait a minute ... who owns the Washington Times? These cult guys all run together in my mind, sort of helter-skelter.
• Fox News not only removing criticism, but also tampering with entries for Al Franken and Keith Olberman.
• The BBC changing the Dubya to mean "Wanker" instead of "Walker" and the New York Times adding "jerk jerk jerk" to George W. Bush's entry. Ah, well, it could be worse. Reuters identified him as a mass murderer.

Now, surely all those edits were cowboy actions by some low-level idiot in those organizations, unsanctioned by anyone in charge. I for one would be shocked, shocked ....

Well, it does make for some fun reading.

While working on a presentation today I was looking for some dates and stumbled across Wikipedia's Online Newspapers entry, which may be the worst page in the entire collection. What little information it has is riddled with inaccuracy. This probably is an illustration of the Cobbler's Children principle. Perhaps some J-prof could armtwist an undergrad into fixing it.

Fortunately we have Dave Carlson's Online Timeline, which is thorough and accurate.