Are journalists anti-business?

yelvington — Sun, 03 Feb 2008 18:37:02 +0000

I was looking over Tim McGuire's syllabus for a class he's teaching at Arizona State, Business and Future of Journalism, and one paragraph really caught my eye:

Every media person you meet will tell you the journalism world you stand to enter has changed profoundly. Much of the blame for that alleged change is laid at the doorstep of “the business side of journalism” and that phrase usually involves a snarl and some spit. And yet any journalist worth any salt at all knows that it is essential that a successful business support quality journalism.

(Emphasis added.)

Are journalists anti-business? Back in the 20th century when I worked at the Minneapolis Star Tribune, where McGuire was editor, we made "diversity" a priority. I always thought our diversity goals weren't diverse enough, because they failed to address some glaring weaknesses in our newsroom culture.

One of those weaknesses was a general lack of understanding of the business world -- not just the "business side" of newspapering, but all small and big business -- that sometimes bubbled up as the "snarl and some spit" that McGuire cites.

I don't buy the self-serving "liberal media" bleat that's been coming from crass right-wing politicians and performers for the last decade or so, but we should recognize our weaknesses and I think this business thing is one of them. I wonder if the "separation of church and state" that's part of the standard J-school indoctrination inadvertently contributes to it. After all, the opposite of sacred is profane.

Or maybe it's simpler than that. We're all the product of our experiences. If you go to college, get a degree in journalism and set out to be a newspaper reporter, you're not living the same kind of life as the entrepreneur who's trying to meet a payroll and obligations. (I had a taste of that life early on, running a cluster of weeklies, and I can tell you it's not a bed of roses.)

Anyway, I have to applaud ASU for making this a required course. In struggling to understand the extraordinary business challenges faced by news companies today, these students may develop a framework that helps them do better journalism by understanding business in general throughout their careers.

yelvington.com - capitalism

Are journalists anti-business?